Reflection for the Second Sunday of Easter

Written on: April 24, 2019

Thank you to Sister Ceil Cosgrove, GNSH for her reflection on the second Sunday of Easter. Sister Ceil is a counselor and therapist, former member of GNSH Leadership. Seen here with an eagle she met in Alaska while visiting our former missions.

Acts 5:12-16
Psalm 118: 2-4, 13-15, 22-24
Revelation 1: 9-11a, 12-13, 17-19
John 20: 19-31 The Gospel for Doubtersthe gift of knowing that it is okay, human, understood, accepted, and blessed, to doubt.

This second Sunday of Easter’s Gospel (John 20:19-31) contains the story of Thomas the Apostle who, for all time, became “Doubting Thomas.” This title so often or, perhaps, exclusively became a pejorative accusation.

How often have you heard or read this Gospel thinking that it was not good that he doubted and, perhaps, not good if we, too, doubt?

I am thinking there is a different lesson to be learned from this gospel.

Thomas had the courage to say he doubted. Obviously, that might not have been easily accepted by those who were caught up in the excitement, reassurance and comfort of having experienced Jesus’ presence in their midst. I would guess they also felt some fear. Can you imagine their response to his lack of belief when they were so captivated, so in awe, not quite able to know what to do with such a powerful experience? Some may have judged Thomas, others may have felt sorry for him. Can we imagine how he must have felt not to have been there with the others – alone, lonely, confused, scared, and bewildered?

Who was Jesus in all of this?  We can read it as being harsh with Thomas; “Have you believed because you have seen? Blessed are those who have not seen and yet have come to believe”.

Or was Jesus being so gentle, “Peace be with you,” and so thoughtful and loving in coming back; not to prove anything to Thomas or to reprimand him but to help him?

  • Did Jesus want to be sure Thomas understood and experienced His risen reality completely?
  • Did He want to support him in his honesty and vulnerability (to own up to not believing can feel pretty unsafe)?
  • Did Jesus want to show him that it was okay to doubt but, also, how much Jesus wanted him to be able to believe?
  • Did He want him to be better prepared to walk the journey?
  • Do Jesus’ actions speak louder than His words?

If He was truly human, Jesus must have known doubt– so He understood. I can’t imagine that He didn’t doubt his Father, His friends and Himself at times. He must have known frightening and painful doubt during His experience in the Garden.

We do doubt.

Actually, belief in Jesus and His story is pretty challenging if you risk thinking about it but we do believe -most or some of the time- and that is not entirely up to us but to a miracle of grace and our choice to be vulnerable in believing.

The Gospel, I suspect, is telling us that Jesus will be here for us as well. I don’t expect that we will get to place our fingers in His side but we can count on Jesus knowing what we need in order to accept, to believe. Jesus wants us to know that we, like Thomas, are loved enough to be sought out in our doubting.

Doubt can lead to incredible belief.


Featured photo: Matt/Unsplash


9 thoughts on “Reflection for the Second Sunday of Easter

  1. Michael McClure says:

    Have a blessed second Sunday of Easter

  2. Eileen White says:

    Thanks Ceil! A powerful reflection.

  3. Clare Cosgrove Andrews says:

    If we never doubt and think about what we believe and the gifts we are given, we do not become stronger in our faith and stronger people.

    Thanks Cecelia Ann! This was a wonderful reflection.

    Clare Cosgrove Andrews

  4. Sister Mary Joan Elias says:

    Thanks, Ceil. So very insightful and comforting especially for me right now. Easter blessings!

  5. Michael McClure says:

    Thank you. Your reflection is very comforting and thoughtful.

  6. greynun says:

    Thanks for this reflection that gives hope for us all in our moments–or days or years–of doubt.

  7. Dotty Fox says:

    Doubt is part of the human condition. I take comfort through this gospel in seeing that Jesus will not turn from us in our time of doubt but will help us embrace and even grow as a result of that doubt.

    Thank you Sister for breaking open that Gospel for us.

  8. greynun says:

    Wonderful, thank you

  9. Mary Elizabeth Looby says:

    I like this! Thanks for your reflection!

Leave a Reply to Clare Cosgrove Andrews Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please be aware that comments are held for moderation and may not post for up to 24 hours. We reserve the right to reject comments that are inappropriate on our website.